Our picks for the five great Hulu movies to watch on Thanksgiving include one of the best modern musicals, an over-the-top adventure, the reinvention of a classic tale, a rousing pirate flick, and a comedy that would be almost impossible to remake without its leading man.

Each night, you look into your lover’s eyes and ask, “Will no legacy media outlet tell me what are the best movies on Hulu?” Luckily, Vanity Fair is here for you. One glance at the platform’s A-to-Z listing reveals that there are almost too many good movies on Hulu to choose from, and it can become a chore to figure out which to choose.

Many families enjoy spending part of their Thanksgiving weekend at the movies. And this year, the holiday weekend is an unusually good weekend for movies, with both new and recently released family-friendly options.